Quick exit
TrustFem
Health & body

Birth control options compared: how each method works and how well

3 min read Updated TrustFem Editorial Team
The short answerThe most effective birth control methods are long-acting ones like the implant and the hormonal or copper coil (IUD), which are more than 99% effective because they don't rely on you remembering anything. The pill, patch, ring and injection are also over 99% effective with perfect use, but less effective with typical use, while condoms are less effective again but are the only method that also protects against sexually transmitted infections. The best method is the one that suits your health, lifestyle and preferences, so it's worth talking options through with a doctor, nurse or sexual health clinic.
Track it privately — free period & symptom trackerPrivate period & symptom tracker — on all your devices, only you can read it

Long-acting methods: the most effective

Long-acting reversible contraception (LARC) works for years once it's in place, and fertility returns once it's removed.

  • Implant — a small flexible rod placed under the skin of your upper arm. Releases a progestogen hormone. Lasts several years. Bleeding patterns can change and may be irregular.
  • Hormonal coil (IUS) — a small T-shaped device placed in the womb that releases progestogen. Lasts several years and often makes periods lighter.
  • Copper coil (IUD) — a hormone-free device placed in the womb. Lasts several years, but can make periods heavier or more painful for some people.

All are more than 99% effective. Fitting involves a short procedure, which some people find uncomfortable, so ask about pain relief options.

Short-acting hormonal methods

  • Combined pill — contains oestrogen and progestogen, taken daily. Can make periods lighter and more regular.
  • Progestogen-only pill — taken daily without a break. An option for many people who can't take oestrogen.
  • Patch — a sticky patch changed weekly.
  • Vaginal ring — a soft ring you insert yourself, usually replaced monthly.
  • Injection — given every few months. It may take a while for fertility to return after stopping.

With perfect use, these are more than 99% effective. With typical use — missed pills, late patches or late injections — they're less effective; for the pill, around 9 in 100 people may get pregnant in a year. Methods containing oestrogen aren't suitable for everyone, for example if you have migraines with aura, a history of blood clots, or smoke and are over 35.

Barrier methods

  • External (male) condoms and internal (female) condoms — used each time you have sex. They're the only methods that also help protect against sexually transmitted infections (STIs).
  • Diaphragm or cap — inserted before sex and used with spermicide.

Barrier methods are less effective than hormonal and long-acting methods with typical use; with condoms, more than 1 in 10 people may get pregnant in a year. Many people use condoms alongside another method for extra protection and STI prevention.

Fertility awareness and permanent methods

Fertility awareness means tracking signs like your temperature, cervical mucus and cycle to identify fertile days. It's hormone-free, but it needs careful daily tracking and is much less effective with typical use. It works best when taught by a trained practitioner.

Sterilisation — tubal surgery for women or vasectomy for men — is more than 99% effective and intended to be permanent. It's a big decision, and long-acting methods are as effective and reversible.

Emergency contraception

If you've had sex without contraception or your method failed, emergency contraception can help prevent pregnancy. Options include emergency pills and the copper coil, which is the most effective. The sooner you use it, the better. A pharmacist, doctor or sexual health clinic can advise quickly.

How to choose what's right for you

Think about:

  • how important it is to avoid pregnancy right now
  • whether you'd rather not think about contraception daily
  • whether you want to avoid hormones
  • how you feel about periods changing — lighter, heavier, irregular or stopping
  • your health history, including migraines, blood clots and medicines you take
  • whether you need STI protection
  • when you might want to get pregnant

Side effects vary from person to person, and if one method doesn't suit you, another might. A doctor, nurse or sexual health clinic can help you compare options confidentially.

When to get medical help

Seek urgent help if you're using hormonal contraception and get pain or swelling in one leg, chest pain, sudden breathlessness, a severe headache or vision changes, as these can be signs of a blood clot. Also get checked if you have severe pelvic pain or think you might be pregnant while using a coil.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most effective form of birth control?

The implant and the coils (hormonal and copper) are among the most effective, at more than 99%, because they work without you needing to remember anything. Sterilisation is similarly effective but intended to be permanent.

What birth control has no hormones?

Hormone-free options include the copper coil, condoms, diaphragms and caps, fertility awareness methods and sterilisation. The copper coil is the most effective of the reversible hormone-free methods.

Does birth control cause weight gain?

Research hasn't shown a clear link between most methods and weight gain, though some people report it, particularly with the injection. If you're worried, talk to your doctor about which methods suit you.

Does birth control protect against STIs?

Only condoms (external and internal) help protect against STIs. If that matters to you, use condoms alongside another method and get tested regularly.

Talk about it with other women

Questions, experiences, what worked for you — in Health, Doctors & Being Heard. You can post anonymously.

Ask a question

Sources & further reading

This guide is general information written to help you understand your options. It is not a substitute for advice from a doctor, lawyer or financial adviser who knows your situation — if you have worrying symptoms, please see a health professional.